Sunday, February 20, 2011

The Stupidity of Aaron Barr - and the Future of Civil Disobedience

This post represents a leap for me, a return to why I started blogging: an attempt to make sense of current events and draw trendlines for where we're headed. It's an activity fraught with opportunities to expose my idiocy, and I don't doubt I will confuse correlation with causation time and time again. Furthermore, the ideas here are by no means my own. Apologies in advance. It's fun to ponder and write, and hopefully not too boring/frustrating to read. So here goes:

A little more than a week ago, the story broke. It didn't register much on the major news networks, but as the rabbit hole went deeper, it got quite interesting. A summary:
  1. Aaron Barr, CEO of HB Gary Federal, tries to unveil the identities of the people he perceives to be the "leaders" of the internet group Anonymous as a stunt to generate publicity (and hopefully clients) for his company.
  2. Bad move. Anon strikes back, hard, hacking into all his social media accounts (including a vulgar but hilarious Twitter hack) and email, putting a large collection of his emails on a popular torrenting website. Arstechnica has a characteristically great (though long) piece outlining the 1 and 2.
  3. In these emails are found multiple presentations, all with the intent of destroying Wikileaks. The most interesting of these is one given in conjunction with Palantir and Berico Technologies to Bank of America's outside law firm, Hunton & Williams (who were apparently soliciting such presentations). 
  4. This presentation included tactics such as fabricating documents to be released to the public, applying personal pressure to key figures in Wikileaks organization (including full bios of families and friends), "cyber attacks against the infrastructure to get data on document submitters," and a "media campaign to push the radical and reckless nature of Wikileaks activities." It went so far as to name Glenn Greenwald (and others) as essential supporters of Wikileaks, and opined that "if pushed [they] will choose professional preservation over cause." In short, it outlined illegal and certainly unethical activities that HB Gary Federal and friends would commit against Wikileaks if hired.
  5. To top it off, it's found that the Justice Department recommended Hunton & Williams to Bank of America.
  6. Everyone starts backpedaling - HB Gary Federal's parent company (HB Gary), their partners, the law firm, etc.
This was followed by a number of good analysis pieces - Glenn Greenwald wrote my favorite. The gall of these firms to write down their illegal activities, the complicity of all parties until it was leaked, the depth of the social connections linking these firms together - all suggest this was business as usual until the presentation was leaked. Clearly, you can call Aaron Barr is stupid, for many reasons (foremost of which was thinking he could mess with Anonymous). But perhaps the most important consequence of his stupidity lies deeper: he gave away the playbook.

The presentations outline the plan of attack of the establishment - though somewhat obvious, it is a disciplined, cohesive strategy that leverages the many weapons they possess: the capabilities of government and large organizations, access to the press, focused use of technology, lots of cash, and others.

Likewise, Anon, and more generally the masses who are disgruntled with the corporatocracy, should give those leaked presentations some serious study, and think critically about their own assets and strategy. Fundamentally, as Egypt and DDoS attacks show us, these groups have the power of the crowds. Digging deeper, we see that this power needs some structure to be unleashed, be it a Facebook or Twitter call to organize at Tahrir Square or the Low Orbit Ion Canon.

As time passes, both sides (and more broadly, all organizations desiring to influence public opinion and make change/maintain the status quo) will become more sophisticated in their approach. The centralized powers like HB Gary (corporations, trade groups, and governments, to name a few) will devote their resources to muddling the debate and spreading misinformation. A few of Burr's leaked emails describe powerful software that can manage large numbers of online personas - coherently linked social media and email accounts. These are being used to sway online discussions and convey the impression of consensus, which can be powerful in swaying public opinion. As an example, think about how easy it would be for a company to hire a blogger to disseminate propaganda and then use these personas and paid traffic to make it seem like the blog is generating a lot of traffic, giving it legitimacy. It's easy to see how an organization with resources can accomplish its ends in a totally opaque and seemingly organic fashion.

But fundamentally, the forces at work and the larger changes in the playing field favor the grassroots protests and Wikileaks of the world. The outsiders have real people behind their cause - and, in many cases, some pretty skillful hackers. It isn't hard to envision a world in which protests - be they against governments, corporations, or people - are taken to the next level. 

Holding up signs outside an oil company whose drilling is killing indigenous people in Peru doesn't really do much. Conversely, educating everyone connected to the CEO - friends, family, etc. - about the atrocities the oil company is perpetrating can have a massive impact on the CEO's life. Imagine the effect of his/her 10 year old daughter, grotesque picture in hand, asking why her parent is responsible for the deaths of so may people.

This is but one example - the possibilities are nearly endless when you combine the ability for large, distributed undertakings of the crowd with a baseline level of organization and communication, which is already in place and only becoming crowd-friendlier. Thus, the future of civil disobedience and protests is open source communities coalescing around systems disruption - Egypt and the DDoS attacks are the tip of the iceberg.  

These tactics will be used by all parties, but in the end I hopeful that the just causes will prevail far more often than not. The internet greatly increases the possibility for transparency, resulting in the greater spread of truth, around which the crowds rally to bring about change. Of course, the path will certainly be filled with confusion and setbacks - for example, the mass persona software programs mentioned above will certainly have success until internet denizens learn of their existence en masse and web companies respond by making social media fraud more difficult. But these will happen, and the freedom of information on the internet will generally work against such tactics, giving them shorter and shorter half-lives.

And so perhaps its naive optimism, but I think the true beneficiary of the sort of targeted systems disruption proposed by Aaron Barr (and carried out by countless others, in all likelihood) will be the disenfranchised crowds seeking justice.


  1. The problem is that the corporate lie machine is now endemic in all of Western society. Look at America. It's so sad to watch Fox, CBS, CNN churn out their bullshit and propaganda whose successful agenda is to dumb down the populace. America lies to its own people constantly and the traitors who have been in control of this once great Nation are corporations and banks with often an open hatred of the people they are supposed to serve. They are liars and thieves, put into and kept in power by lies. It's all about keeping power in the ruling classes hands but I fear their days are numbered. The likes of anonymous indicates that the dreamers are awakening from their slumber and they are getting very angry... very angry indeed. And they are legion... everybody and nobody... they do not forgive! They do not forget!

  2. Though someone has created a fake Hell Correspondence webpage, folks are still adding the names of school bullies and animal abusers to Ai's site -- and she is dutifully ferrying the cursed to eternal torment. There's a catch, though : Those who seek revenge (and Ai's services) must pay witrh their own souls. deliverable upon death!

  3. Vinay Dixit: Clearly, there are varying degrees of interest in buying or even fake products across various wealthy consumer prada replica segments as well as across product categories. Our research indicates that many consumers have deep desire for "real" (and very expensive luxury goods) despite replica wathces high availability of (cheap) fake goods. There is a difference though between some wealthy consumer louis vuitton replica segments who will not think to buy fake and those who will comfortably mix the two. For example, over 90% the segment disagree with buying fake watches and jewelry chanel replica, whereas the figure is only 42% for the to Earth segment.

  4. oakley sunglasses wholesale,
    bottega veneta outlet online,
    nike soccer shoes,
    new england patriots jerseys,
    louis vuitton bags,
    redskins jerseys,
    tommy hilfiger outlet,
    blackhawks jersey,
    cheap jordans,
    true religion canada,
    fred perry polo shirts,
    north face outlet,
    ugg boots,
    boston celtics jersey,
    ysl outlet online,
    ray-ban sunglasses,
    babyliss pro,
    chicago bulls jersey,
    michael kors outlet,
    boston celtics,

  5. PUBG Mobile lite for Android PUBG Mobile APK Download free and safe download. PUBG Mobile lite latest version

  6. Erotika spa is offering multiple type of massage services, Body to Body Massage, Happy ending Massage, Erotic Massage, Sensual massage, B2b massage, Sandwich Massage, Swedish massage, Aroma oil Massage, tantra massage with price in Delhi, Female to male body Massage center in Delhi.

    Read More:

  7. Low testosterone level achieved numerous issues for men. It causes significant issues in your sexual exhibitions and furthermore emerges leap in your physical exhibitions. For a rec center going, it is difficult to manage work withdrawals in the exercise center with a low testosterone level.Try Enduraflex Testosteron Booster for More Energy

  8. Low testosterone level achieved numerous issues for men. It causes significant issues in your sexual exhibitions and furthermore emerges leap in your physical exhibitions. For a rec center going, it is difficult to manage work withdrawals in the exercise center with a low testosterone level.Try Enduraflex Testosteron Booster for More Energy

  9. Mgiwebzone offer Best Internet marketing services to improve your online presence. No matter which industry your business belongs to, chances are you have to deal with everyday challenges and fierce competition. The experts at MgiWebzone will reshape and redefine your website’s status and standing in the Search Engines.
    For more info call us at: (+91) 7503544039
    E-mail on

    Read More at:

  10. Cosmetic surgery is where a person chooses to have an operation or invasive medical procedure, to change their physical appearance for cosmetic rather than medical reasons.
    Non-surgical cosmetic procedures, such as Botox and dermal fillers - typically used to relax or fill crease lines - do not involve surgery. However, there are still risks attached.
    Cosmetic surgery is a unique discipline of medicine focused on enhancing appearance through surgical and medical techniques. Cosmetic surgery can be performed on all areas of the head, neck, and body. Because treated areas function properly but lack aesthetic appeal, cosmetic surgery is elective.
    Read more:

  11. Anthropology Optional for UPSC
    by Pradip Sarkar
    New Batch Starting from 26th Nov. 2018
    Online/Offline Class also Available
    Admission Open, Join Now

    Call: 8700922126 || 011-2875 6962 || 9718354962
    Address: 17A/44, W.E.A. 3rd Floor, Near Karol Bagh Metro Station (Pillar No. 99), New Delhi- 110005.


  12. Engineering mechanics lectures
    from Savitribai Phule Pune University - Information Technology Engineering - SEM II

  13. Wethecoders is one of the leading online assignment help services. wethecoders always take step towards your satisfaction. We work hard so that you can get good grades. Our prime motto is to help you to get good grades in your assignment, project and homework. Our team is professional and knowledgeable. We are here to help you 24/7. Try once to take the advantage of our services and we assure you that you will get surely the best result.

    Read More :

  14. Website Design For Education Institution In Delhi India

    We offer complete professional Website Design Solutions,As a website design company we offer a full-circle approach in responsive website designing and web development services. Our website designing services covers strategic planning, business intelligence, creative, application development, digital marketing, seo services and e-commerce solutions.

    Mgiwebzone offer Best Internet marketing services to improve your online presence. No matter which industry your business belongs to, chances are you have to deal with everyday challenges and fierce competition. The experts at MgiWebzonewill reshape and redefine your website’s status and standing in the Search Engines.
    For more info call us at: (+91) 7503544039
    E-mail on

    Read More:

  15. Leaser Hair Treatment In Amritsar

    Laser therapies are medical treatments that use focused light. Unlike most light sources, light from a laser (which stands for light amplification by stimulated emission of radiation) is tuned to specific wavelengths. This allows it to be focused into powerful beams. Laser light is so intense that it can be used to shape diamonds or cut steel.
    In medicine, lasers allow surgeons to work at high levels of precision by focusing on a small area, damaging less of the surrounding tissue. If you have laser therapy, you may experience less pain, swelling, and scarring than with traditional surgery. However, laser therapy can be expensive and require repeated treatments.
    What is laser therapy used for?

    Lasers may be useful in treating the very early stages of some cancers, including..

    For cancer, laser therapy is usually used alongside other treatments, such as surgery, chemotherapy, or radiation.

    Read more:

  16. Dublin Airport Taxi

    We provides best dublin taxi and shuttle services, such as getting our clients at airports, ports and train stations and giving support services at congresses, events and shows, besides organizing trips to the most varied destinations.

    A highlight of our activities is the City Tour – a dublin taxi service that takes our clients to any place inside or outside the city of Dublin, so they can get acquainted with what the city and the outskirts have the to offer at best.

    Besides the safety, quality and professionalism, we pride ourselves for the comfort we offer to our guests. We dedicate the upmost care to deliver to our clients the necessary well-being during their trip, counting with a modern fleet of vehicles to tend to their needs.

    Read More:

  17. Financial Divorce In Brisbane Australia

    If you are thinking of separating or you already have, then financial certainty is necessary.

    Financial Planners are not just there to provide advice on stocks and bonds but to also provide

    solutions for your complex situation. To talk about you and what your needs and wants are. Your needs

    and wants will be different to when you were married and a new strategy for you, can be put in place

    easily to ensure your new blueprint is clear. It’s important to make your financial decisions before a

    settlement or negotiations have started as your financials need to be identified so that all your

    options are considered.

    Read More:

  18. Download, Install & Activate MS Office Product by visiting the official website of MS Office. Click on the following link to know more about MS Office |

    Download office setup from here. here you will get full information about Office setup For Visiting Our Website kindly click on this link.

  20. You can install office setup by visiting official website of MS Office.

  21. Transformer oil filtration system - The usage of all HERING EOK Transformer oil purifying plants enhances the properties properties of the transformer insulation by reducing the water content inside the fluids and substances. Additionally, our EOK Series can carry out an oil degasification and eliminate the acids. This generates better acting transformer insulating material and, consequently, builds the foundation for advanced transformer performance